Dreamtime: The Gil-Garem

We rated this book:


Dreamtime: The Gil-Garem’s story involves Edmund Mortani, a soldier who fought for the Sorisentine Dominion during the Garemoth Wars. In those wars, he lost his wife, Eurydice, on a mission. He continues to be haunted by dreams and visions of her 10 years after the war ends. When robot attacks begin again, Edmund suspects the Gil-Garem have come back to life, even though they appeared to be eradicated a decade earlier.

From the start, it is clear that Dreamtime: The Gil-Garem was once a screenplay. Character actions are written in the present tense, and several errors in grammar, spelling, and formatting show that a good spell-checker and the Chicago Manual of Style were not contributing resources to this sci-fi epic. Upon finishing the book, I found out the author had created a “hybrid tense system” for writing around his screenplay format. While it was a good effort, subverting English grammar didn’t completely iron out the difference in experience between screenplay and novel, and, ultimately, the author would have done better to start from scratch and use proper storytelling conventions.

It’s difficult for a reader to grow attached to a character without even knowing what they look like. If this book were to be made into a movie, viewers would have the luxury of seeing what Edmund looked like, as portrayed by an actor, along with the other characters and the scenery. For the first several chapters, I felt blind, like I was feeling my way along the narrative with indistinguishable human beings and nondescript robots doing things. While it might have slowed the pacing, I would have enjoyed the book more for its ability to paint a clear picture of the action in my mind.

The atmosphere of the book reminded me of a Star Trek fan fiction, intriguing in its development and ideas, but amateurish in its execution. However, a major strong point the book has going for it is its action sequences. Edmund and his crew go on missions to determine what the robots are and where they’re coming from, and the fight scenes are described in richer detail than many of the other elements of the book. Clearly depicted scenery, deeply developed characters, and a coherent adventure plot are the cornerstones of a good sci-fi novel.

I will gladly enjoy a several-hundred-page space opera because I know from its in-depth world and character building, as well as the narrative’s ability to paint clear pictures and develop tension and conflict that it’s good science fiction. In addition, good science fiction addresses deeper themes: the search for utopia, the human condition, the hubris of man, or leadership under duress. While some broader ideas were touched upon, such as Edmund’s sense of loss and the relationship between artificial and organic intelligence, the themes weren’t completely clear.

Dreamtime: The Gil-Garem was a good start; the shell of a more developed story, but it is sure to leave readers wanting more.

Reviewed By:

Author C. S. Benjamin
Star Count /5
Format Trade
Page Count 321 pages
Publisher New Classic Press
Publish Date 1-Jan-15
ISBN 9780986208607
Bookshop.org Buy this Book
Issue March 2016
Category Science Fiction & Fantasy


There are no reviews yet.

Be the first to review “Dreamtime: The Gil-Garem”